Ive clicker trained a lot of dogs before, some my own and some other peoples pets,and Ive never seen any training method as fast or effective. That being said, Im sure there are some incredible trainers out there who have never used a clicker and I applaud them, but I found what works for me and I love seeing dogs figuring stuff out with a clicker! If some people arent into treats and clickers that fine too... but I have a question for those who know about it.
My mini schnauzer is 4 months old and I clicker train her for 5 minutes three to four times a day. This is my first time having a schnauzer, or even a purebred dog with slightly more predictable traits, so I know she is more prone to behaviours Im not used to. However, she is obsessed with food and when a treat is offered after a click she NEVER takes it, but instead gets so excited she buries her face in my hand, misses the treat entirely and then careers around the floor searching for treaty smells - and the clicked moment is lost every time and gathering back up her concentration is hard. Does anyone have advice on getting her to calm down about food, and just take the treat when offered rathen than going nuts.
Also, and more on my search list, is an alternative to clicking without a treat. Does anyone know about this? I was reading about training military dogs amd using a ball or favourite toy as a reward every time after a click.. I thought this would be more of a distraction as she usually grabs toys and run around with them and gets very excited (which is gorgeous and hilarious, I dont wanna lose her joy) but she is already distracted enough with food, so maybe the difference wouldnt be that great. Does anyone know anything about clicker training without food as the reward, andand any good results on this, or good websites on the subject. I live in china where google is blocked countrywide so all my search engines are predominantly chinese, which means I dont usually get great results searching for info.
Thanks so much!
Fish
Clicker training without treats?
- FishMina
- Puppy
- Posts: 5
- Joined: 16 Feb 2017, 01:43
- First Name: Fish
- Dog #1: Schnauzer
- is a: B/S Mini Bitch
- Dog #2: Tudou (mixed breed)
- Location: Hohhot, Inner Mongolia, China
- Dawnspell
- Moderator
- Posts: 4716
- Joined: 05 Mar 2013, 18:27
- First Name: Alison
- Dog #1: Barney RIP 8/3/19
- is a: White Mini Dog
- Born: 06 Feb 2013
- Dog #2: Jasper
- is a: White Mini Dog
- Born: 25 Apr 2019
- Location: Guernsey
Re: Clicker training without treats?
I'd start clicker training to teach impulse control over her food obsession.
Hold a treat in your closed hand. From what you say she'll go mad sniffing and nose poking trying to get the treat. The moment she stops, which may take a while with her, click and give the treat.
Keep doing this and eventually she will learn the way to get the treat is not to go sniffing at your hand but to sit and ignore it.
What do you use as treats ? This can affect how they react, low value for home and high value for out and about.
When using a toy for training it is normally one specific toy that you load as being high value, so they only get it when training and giving the correct behaviour. It is never used for general playtime. Barney is toy orientated no interest in food when out and about whatsoever. I carry a squeaky plastic ball in my pocket when on walks. If I want him back to me quick one squeak and he comes hes then is allowed a couple of throws of fetch and it goes back in my pocket to keep its high value.
You could try a ball on a rope and teach tug as her reward then she wouldn't be running off. Kikopup on youtube has a video of how to get a dog interested in a toy as reward. In fact all of her clicker training videos are good.
Hold a treat in your closed hand. From what you say she'll go mad sniffing and nose poking trying to get the treat. The moment she stops, which may take a while with her, click and give the treat.
Keep doing this and eventually she will learn the way to get the treat is not to go sniffing at your hand but to sit and ignore it.
What do you use as treats ? This can affect how they react, low value for home and high value for out and about.
When using a toy for training it is normally one specific toy that you load as being high value, so they only get it when training and giving the correct behaviour. It is never used for general playtime. Barney is toy orientated no interest in food when out and about whatsoever. I carry a squeaky plastic ball in my pocket when on walks. If I want him back to me quick one squeak and he comes hes then is allowed a couple of throws of fetch and it goes back in my pocket to keep its high value.
You could try a ball on a rope and teach tug as her reward then she wouldn't be running off. Kikopup on youtube has a video of how to get a dog interested in a toy as reward. In fact all of her clicker training videos are good.
Our first family dog
Barney - Pocketpark Biali Eyebright 6/2/13 - 8/3/19 Gone too soon
Motto for owners who groom their own Schnauzers -"Never mind it'll soon grow back"
Barney - Pocketpark Biali Eyebright 6/2/13 - 8/3/19 Gone too soon
Motto for owners who groom their own Schnauzers -"Never mind it'll soon grow back"
- FishMina
- Puppy
- Posts: 5
- Joined: 16 Feb 2017, 01:43
- First Name: Fish
- Dog #1: Schnauzer
- is a: B/S Mini Bitch
- Dog #2: Tudou (mixed breed)
- Location: Hohhot, Inner Mongolia, China
Re: Clicker training without treats?
Ayaa that first bit about clicking to teach 'dont go mad for treats' is awesome, fantatic idea, thanks so much! I used teeny tiny pieces of chopped up sausage or any meat for a while but the smell was so strong she would just run around and around smelling for it, not even realising it was in my hand and unable to calm down - but even now I train with kibble and she still goes mental for it, anything seems to get her food-oriented! I have a strict rule to never allow begging and treats from my own plate/table, but she has been so mad about food that she will shake all over even at the sound of kibble since we got her.
The other thing - if I stopped using treats and instead a high value toy, which id really like to do, could I use it in the same way as, the second she does the action, I click an give the toy? And in that case, do I play with her for a moment, or take it back after the first throw, or let her play with it herself before taking it back? Eg haha how long should the toy rewards be, and how do I keep the focus on 'im taking it back now, lets keep working' rather than 'im stealing your fun again and again! Mwahaha'
Hah thaks so much for your reply!
The other thing - if I stopped using treats and instead a high value toy, which id really like to do, could I use it in the same way as, the second she does the action, I click an give the toy? And in that case, do I play with her for a moment, or take it back after the first throw, or let her play with it herself before taking it back? Eg haha how long should the toy rewards be, and how do I keep the focus on 'im taking it back now, lets keep working' rather than 'im stealing your fun again and again! Mwahaha'
Hah thaks so much for your reply!
- zeta1454
- Moderator
- Posts: 5144
- Joined: 19 May 2011, 16:58
- First Name: Leigh
- Dog #1: Magic
- is a: P/S Mini Bitch
- Born: 20 Apr 2010
- Dog #2: Trilby
- is a: P/S Mini Bitch
- Born: 15 Mar 2012
- Dog #3: Pip
- Born: 21 Feb 2014
- is a: P/S Mini Bitch
- Location: North Yorkshire
- Contact:
Re: Clicker training without treats?
I don't know how easy it would be for you to get a book ( hard copy or Kindle) in China but I would really recommend this one, if you can
https://www.amazon.co.uk/When-Pigs-Fly- ... gs+can+fly" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
https://www.amazon.co.uk/When-Pigs-Fly- ... gs+can+fly" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Dogs are not our whole life, but they make our lives whole. ~Roger Caras
Magic - Silversocks Sharade at Darksprite
Trilby - Darksprite Rosa Bud
https://m.facebook.com/pages/category/C ... 916994967/
Magic - Silversocks Sharade at Darksprite
Trilby - Darksprite Rosa Bud
https://m.facebook.com/pages/category/C ... 916994967/
- ZiiPAngelclaws
- Member
- Posts: 1143
- Joined: 25 Aug 2013, 18:25
- First Name: Hayley
Re: Clicker training without treats?
my girl is scared of the clicker so instead we say "yes!!" and then treat or praise, Elica is very praise orientated, it works for us.
-
- Member
- Posts: 1691
- Joined: 09 May 2012, 15:28
- First Name: Cat
- Dog #1: Lola
- is a: B/S Mini Bitch
- Born: 13 Mar 2012
- Dog #2: Pixie
- is a: P/S Mini Bitch
- Born: 21 Feb 2014
- Location: Birmingham
Re: Clicker training without treats?
If she is acting over the top with the treats you are offering, they are too high value. Try with something like small piece of cucumber or apple and see how she reacts then.
Also try not having the treats in your hand but in a bowl out of reach. Only reach for the treat after you have clicked.
You might try clicking for eye contact to train focus and attention on you.
Also try not having the treats in your hand but in a bowl out of reach. Only reach for the treat after you have clicked.
You might try clicking for eye contact to train focus and attention on you.